assessment of internal control and risk assessment
I. Governance and Leadership
- Identify key positions within the organization.
- Map out reporting lines and hierarchies.
- Ensure clarity on decision-making authority.
- Check for alignment with strategic objectives.
- Gather feedback from staff on structure effectiveness.
- Define key roles within the organization.
- Document responsibilities for each position.
- Ensure employees understand their specific duties.
- Evaluate overlap or gaps in responsibilities.
- Solicit input from team members for improvements.
- Identify existing communication methods and tools.
- Assess frequency and effectiveness of communication.
- Gather feedback on communication clarity.
- Evaluate accessibility of information for all staff.
- Implement improvements based on staff feedback.
- Review board structure and composition.
- Evaluate meeting frequency and agenda effectiveness.
- Assess decision-making processes and outcomes.
- Check for alignment with organizational goals.
- Solicit feedback from board members on effectiveness.
- Examine current mission and vision statements.
- Assess relevance to operational practices.
- Evaluate how values are integrated into culture.
- Identify gaps between strategic goals and mission.
- Engage staff for input on alignment.
- Review existing code of conduct documents.
- Assess clarity and accessibility for staff.
- Evaluate training provided on ethics policies.
- Check compliance with legal and regulatory standards.
- Gather feedback on ethical dilemmas faced by staff.
- Review current training offerings for leaders.
- Evaluate participation rates and feedback.
- Assess alignment with organizational needs.
- Identify gaps in skills and knowledge.
- Solicit input from leaders on training effectiveness.
- Evaluate the strategic planning framework used.
- Assess stakeholder involvement in planning.
- Check the alignment of goals with mission.
- Review monitoring mechanisms for progress.
- Gather feedback on the planning process from staff.
- Identify key stakeholders and their interests.
- Assess current engagement methods and frequency.
- Gather feedback on stakeholder satisfaction.
- Evaluate impact of engagement on decision making.
- Identify areas for improvement in engagement.
- Review decision-making frameworks in place.
- Evaluate timeliness and transparency of decisions.
- Gather staff feedback on decision impact.
- Check alignment with strategic goals.
- Identify areas for improvement in processes.
- Examine existing conflict resolution policies.
- Assess accessibility and clarity for staff.
- Evaluate the effectiveness of resolution outcomes.
- Gather feedback on staff experiences with processes.
- Identify gaps or areas for improvement.
- Review compliance policies and procedures.
- Assess training provided on compliance issues.
- Evaluate monitoring and reporting mechanisms.
- Check for adherence to industry regulations.
- Identify areas needing improvement in compliance.
- Review existing performance metrics and KPIs.
- Assess data collection methods and accuracy.
- Evaluate frequency and clarity of reporting.
- Gather feedback on usefulness of reports.
- Identify opportunities for enhancing measurement systems.
II. Financial Controls
- Verify cash register reconciliation practices.
- Observe cash handling during peak hours.
- Ensure secure storage of cash.
- Review employee access to cash.
- Check for regular cash audits.
- Review journal entries for accuracy.
- Confirm timely posting of transactions.
- Check reconciliation frequency and documentation.
- Ensure systematic error correction processes.
- Verify integration with accounting software.
- Ensure dual approval for large expenditures.
- Verify payroll processing and approval flow.
- Check documentation for expense reimbursements.
- Review compliance with budget constraints.
- Assess timeliness of approvals.
- Verify inventory tracking methods.
- Check for regular physical counts.
- Assess accuracy of inventory records.
- Ensure proper storage conditions.
- Review procedures for handling discrepancies.
- Review financial statement preparation procedures.
- Verify compliance with accounting standards.
- Check for timely reporting deadlines.
- Assess internal review processes.
- Ensure clarity and transparency of reports.
- Identify key financial roles and responsibilities.
- Ensure no single individual has control of all aspects.
- Review cross-training practices.
- Assess oversight mechanisms.
- Check for regular audits of duties.
- Review past budget performance comparisons.
- Assess assumptions used in forecasts.
- Check for stakeholder input in budgets.
- Ensure regular budget reviews.
- Verify alignment with strategic goals.
- Review credit policies and risk assessments.
- Check aging reports for overdue accounts.
- Ensure timely invoicing and collection processes.
- Assess payment approval workflows.
- Verify reconciliation of accounts.
- Review document retention policies.
- Ensure secure storage of sensitive information.
- Check for regular backups of financial data.
- Assess access controls for financial records.
- Verify compliance with legal requirements.
- Verify documentation of all assets.
- Check compliance with depreciation methods.
- Assess tracking of asset disposals.
- Review physical asset verification processes.
- Ensure regular updates to asset records.
- Check authorization processes for transfers.
- Ensure secure access to online banking.
- Review transaction monitoring procedures.
- Assess fraud detection measures.
- Verify compliance with security standards.
- Review existing fraud prevention policies.
- Check for employee training on fraud awareness.
- Assess whistleblower protection measures.
- Evaluate monitoring of unusual transactions.
- Review incident response procedures.
- Identify applicable regulations.
- Assess adherence to reporting requirements.
- Check for internal compliance audits.
- Review training on compliance topics.
- Ensure timely updates on regulatory changes.
- Review training programs for financial staff.
- Assess staff qualifications and certifications.
- Verify ongoing professional development.
- Check for performance evaluations.
- Ensure clarity of roles and responsibilities.
III. Operational Controls
- Review local health codes and regulations.
- Conduct inspections of food handling areas.
- Verify employee adherence to safety protocols.
- Document compliance findings and corrective actions.
- Schedule regular training on health standards.
- Verify sourcing of ingredients meets safety standards.
- Inspect food storage conditions regularly.
- Evaluate cooking and temperature control procedures.
- Implement a tracking system for food recalls.
- Conduct periodic taste tests for quality assurance.
- Review training materials for relevance and clarity.
- Assess employee understanding through quizzes or feedback.
- Track attendance and completion rates of training.
- Solicit employee feedback for program improvement.
- Update training materials regularly to reflect changes.
- Review vendor selection criteria and contracts.
- Assess the reliability and quality of vendors.
- Monitor vendor performance through regular evaluations.
- Establish a process for rotating vendors when necessary.
- Document any issues and resolutions with vendors.
- Schedule audits at regular intervals.
- Involve cross-functional teams for diverse insights.
- Document findings and prioritize areas for action.
- Follow up on implementation of audit recommendations.
- Use audit results to inform continuous improvement.
- Implement periodic inventory counts and reconciliations.
- Use technology for tracking inventory levels.
- Establish protocols for handling discrepancies.
- Train staff on proper inventory management techniques.
- Review supplier delivery accuracy regularly.
- Review maintenance logs for adherence to schedules.
- Inspect equipment for signs of wear or malfunction.
- Solicit employee feedback on equipment reliability.
- Adjust schedules based on equipment usage patterns.
- Document maintenance activities for compliance.
- Evaluate staff adherence to service standards.
- Collect customer feedback through surveys.
- Conduct role-playing sessions for service training.
- Review complaint handling procedures for effectiveness.
- Ensure protocols are accessible and understood by staff.
- Review SOP documentation for clarity and completeness.
- Conduct training sessions on SOP adherence.
- Monitor compliance through regular observations.
- Solicit employee feedback on SOP effectiveness.
- Update SOPs as needed based on operational changes.
- Identify relevant KPIs for each operation area.
- Collect and analyze performance data regularly.
- Share results with staff to encourage improvement.
- Benchmark performance against industry standards.
- Adjust strategies based on KPI analysis.
- Review existing environmental policies and practices.
- Conduct audits of waste management and recycling efforts.
- Train staff on sustainability initiatives.
- Document compliance with environmental laws.
- Set goals for reducing environmental impact.
- Ensure clear protocols for reporting incidents.
- Conduct drills for emergency response scenarios.
- Analyze past incidents for lessons learned.
- Update response procedures based on feedback.
- Train staff on incident management protocols.
- Review existing communication tools and methods.
- Gather employee feedback on communication effectiveness.
- Implement regular updates through meetings or emails.
- Encourage open channels for employee suggestions.
- Evaluate communication effectiveness periodically.
- Identify potential operational risks and disruptions.
- Review existing risk management plans and procedures.
- Conduct scenario planning for various emergencies.
- Train staff on risk mitigation strategies.
- Regularly update risk assessments based on incidents.
IV. Information Technology Controls
- Verify encryption of transactions.
- Check for software updates and patches.
- Assess user authentication methods.
- Evaluate physical security of terminals.
- Review logging of transactions.
- Conduct penetration testing on systems.
- Verify frequency of backups.
- Check storage location (onsite/offsite).
- Test recovery process effectiveness.
- Ensure data integrity checks are performed.
- Document backup procedures clearly.
- Review access controls to backup data.
- Review user roles and permissions.
- Assess multi-factor authentication implementation.
- Check for regular access reviews.
- Ensure least privilege principle is applied.
- Document access control policies.
- Evaluate monitoring of access logs.
- Assess accuracy of generated reports.
- Verify data sources and integration.
- Check user access to analytics tools.
- Evaluate compliance with data governance standards.
- Review training on reporting tools.
- Document reporting processes and methodologies.
- Review firewall configuration settings.
- Check for regular updates and patches.
- Test intrusion detection alerts.
- Assess logging and reporting capabilities.
- Evaluate incident response to alerts.
- Document firewall and IDS policies.
- Verify installation on all endpoints.
- Check update frequency for virus definitions.
- Assess scanning schedule and coverage.
- Evaluate incident response to malware detection.
- Review user training on malware threats.
- Document antivirus policies and procedures.
- Verify encryption standards used.
- Assess key management practices.
- Check for encryption on all sensitive data.
- Evaluate compliance with encryption regulations.
- Document encryption policies.
- Review encryption implementation processes.
- Review user account creation procedures.
- Assess deactivation processes for terminated employees.
- Check password policies and complexity requirements.
- Evaluate regular audits of user accounts.
- Document user account management policies.
- Ensure access is revoked promptly.
- Schedule regular vulnerability scans.
- Assess remediation timelines for findings.
- Document results of penetration tests.
- Evaluate effectiveness of security controls.
- Review testing scope and methodologies.
- Ensure follow-up on identified vulnerabilities.
- Assess clarity and comprehensiveness of plans.
- Check for regular testing and updates.
- Evaluate roles and responsibilities assigned.
- Document incident response training conducted.
- Review post-incident analysis processes.
- Ensure communication protocols are defined.
- Review third-party risk assessment processes.
- Check security certifications of vendors.
- Assess data handling and storage practices.
- Evaluate incident response capabilities of vendors.
- Document vendor security policies.
- Ensure contracts include security requirements.
- Review training content for relevance.
- Check frequency of training sessions.
- Assess employee engagement and understanding.
- Document training attendance and completion.
- Evaluate follow-up assessments of knowledge.
- Ensure training includes current threats.
- Check access controls and monitoring.
- Evaluate environmental controls (e.g., temperature).
- Assess fire suppression systems.
- Document physical security policies.
- Ensure visitor logs are maintained.
- Review surveillance measures in place.
- Assess frequency of software updates.
- Check documentation of patches applied.
- Evaluate testing procedures for patches.
- Document rollback procedures for failed updates.
- Ensure all systems are included in management.
- Review compliance with patching policies.
- Check for comprehensive logging of events.
- Assess monitoring tools and alerts.
- Review incident response to unusual activity.
- Document logging policies and retention.
- Evaluate regular reviews of logs.
- Ensure compliance with logging regulations.
- Review data handling and processing practices.
- Check for documentation of compliance procedures.
- Evaluate employee training on regulations.
- Assess incident response for data breaches.
- Document compliance audits conducted.
- Ensure regular updates on regulatory changes.
- Assess security of remote access methods.
- Check for user authentication requirements.
- Evaluate monitoring of remote connections.
- Document remote access policies.
- Ensure employee training on remote security.
- Review access logs for remote sessions.
- Review change request documentation.
- Assess testing procedures for changes.
- Check for rollback plans in place.
- Document approval processes for changes.
- Evaluate post-implementation reviews.
- Ensure compliance with change management policies.
- Review risk assessment processes.
- Assess alignment of cybersecurity with business goals.
- Check for regular updates to risk assessments.
- Document integration efforts and strategies.
- Evaluate stakeholder involvement in risk management.
- Ensure communication of risks across the organization.
V. Risk Assessment
- Conduct brainstorming sessions with team members.
- Review past incidents and near misses.
- Analyze industry trends and regulatory changes.
- Engage with customers for feedback on potential risks.
- Utilize risk assessment tools and frameworks.
- Review existing policies and procedures.
- Assess past incidents to determine effectiveness.
- Solicit feedback from employees on current strategies.
- Benchmark against industry best practices.
- Identify gaps in current strategies.
- Examine current incident reporting protocols.
- Ensure clarity in reporting responsibilities.
- Assess response times and outcomes of past incidents.
- Collect input from employees on the process.
- Update procedures based on findings.
- Utilize a risk matrix to categorize risks.
- Rate risks based on historical data and forecasts.
- Engage team members for their insights.
- Consider both financial and operational impacts.
- Document assessments for future reference.
- Schedule assessments on a quarterly or biannual basis.
- Incorporate changes in business operations or environment.
- Review new technologies and market developments.
- Engage external consultants when necessary.
- Update risk registers accordingly.
- Identify stakeholders from various departments.
- Facilitate workshops or meetings to gather input.
- Encourage open discussion and collaboration.
- Document stakeholder feedback for analysis.
- Ensure representation from management and staff.
- Define acceptable risk levels for different areas.
- Communicate tolerances to all stakeholders.
- Use quantitative and qualitative measures.
- Review tolerances periodically based on changes.
- Incorporate tolerances into strategic planning.
- Create a risk register to track risks.
- Use a scoring system for prioritization.
- Ensure documentation is accessible to relevant parties.
- Regularly review and update the register.
- Communicate priorities to the team.
- Identify responsible parties for each action.
- Set clear timelines and milestones.
- Allocate necessary resources for implementation.
- Monitor progress regularly and adapt as needed.
- Ensure actions are documented and communicated.
- Establish a monitoring system for key indicators.
- Review industry news and regulatory updates.
- Engage with professional networks for insights.
- Adjust risk assessments based on findings.
- Maintain flexibility in risk management strategies.
- Set a regular schedule for reviews.
- Incorporate feedback from stakeholders.
- Analyze the effectiveness of past assessments.
- Document changes and the rationale behind them.
- Ensure alignment with organizational goals.
- Prepare concise reports summarizing findings.
- Use visual aids like charts and graphs.
- Schedule presentations for key stakeholders.
- Encourage questions and discussions post-presentation.
- Document communication for future reference.
- Develop training materials covering risk topics.
- Schedule regular training sessions.
- Use real-life scenarios for practical understanding.
- Encourage a culture of open communication.
- Evaluate training effectiveness through feedback.
- Create anonymous channels for feedback.
- Regularly solicit input from all levels of staff.
- Review feedback during risk assessment meetings.
- Adapt processes based on constructive criticisms.
- Communicate changes made as a result of feedback.
VI. Monitoring and Review
- Define audit frequency (monthly, quarterly).
- Assign responsibilities to audit team members.
- Prepare a detailed audit plan outlining scope and objectives.
- Communicate schedule to all relevant staff.
- Ensure resources are allocated for effective audits.
- Collect feedback through surveys, suggestion boxes, or meetings.
- Analyze feedback data for trends and common issues.
- Share findings with management for action.
- Implement changes based on actionable feedback.
- Communicate outcomes to staff and customers.
- Gather data on previously identified issues.
- Review implemented corrective actions for effectiveness.
- Document results and any ongoing challenges.
- Adjust corrective measures as necessary.
- Report findings to relevant stakeholders.
- Conduct employee surveys on compliance perceptions.
- Observe behaviors related to compliance and accountability.
- Identify gaps in understanding or commitment.
- Provide feedback to leadership on cultural issues.
- Develop initiatives to strengthen compliance culture.
- Schedule regular review dates (annually, bi-annually).
- Involve key stakeholders in the review process.
- Identify changes in regulations or business environment.
- Update policies to reflect current best practices.
- Disseminate updated policies to all staff.
- Define relevant KPIs aligned with objectives.
- Collect data for each KPI regularly.
- Analyze KPI results to identify trends.
- Report KPI findings in management meetings.
- Adjust strategies based on KPI outcomes.
- Schedule regular training sessions (quarterly, bi-annually).
- Develop training materials covering key topics.
- Engage experienced trainers or facilitators.
- Evaluate training effectiveness through assessments.
- Encourage feedback from participants for improvement.
- Identify documents requiring updates.
- Assign responsibility for revisions.
- Ensure changes are approved by management.
- Distribute updated documents to all staff.
- Establish a version control system.
- Identify qualified external auditors or consultants.
- Schedule assessments at regular intervals.
- Provide necessary documentation and access.
- Review external findings and recommendations.
- Implement changes based on external assessments.
- Collect and categorize incident reports.
- Identify patterns or recurring issues.
- Evaluate the effectiveness of current controls.
- Develop action plans for identified improvements.
- Communicate findings to relevant teams.
- Establish anonymous reporting mechanisms.
- Promote a culture of openness and trust.
- Regularly remind staff about reporting options.
- Evaluate reported concerns for validity.
- Act on suggestions and communicate outcomes.
- Schedule follow-up assessments at defined intervals.
- Review previous risk documentation for context.
- Engage relevant departments in the assessment.
- Document changes in risk status and actions taken.
- Report findings to management for review.
- Identify relevant industry standards for benchmarking.
- Collect data on current internal control practices.
- Compare internal practices against benchmarks.
- Document gaps and recommend improvements.
- Engage management in strategy discussions based on findings.
- Compile findings into a structured report.
- Share reports with management and relevant stakeholders.
- Highlight key areas of concern and recommendations.
- Establish a feedback loop for stakeholders.
- Ensure ongoing communication of updates and progress.
Use in Manifestly