Technical Engineering Project audit for mechanical, civil, EIC calculations and drawings packages

1. Project Documentation Review

2. Mechanical Engineering Audit

  • Confirm adherence to applicable design codes.
  • Check for proper load assumptions and boundary conditions.
  • Validate calculations for accuracy and consistency.
  • Ensure documentation supports all calculations.
  • Review assumptions made during calculations.
  • Cross-check drawings against relevant standards.
  • Ensure all required dimensions and tolerances are present.
  • Verify the use of standard symbols and notations.
  • Check for consistency across all related drawings.
  • Confirm that drawings are up-to-date with revisions.
  • Review material properties against project requirements.
  • Ensure compliance with industry standards for materials.
  • Assess the rationale for material selections.
  • Verify sourcing and availability of specified materials.
  • Check for sustainability considerations in material choices.
  • Evaluate the methodologies used for simulations.
  • Check for appropriate boundary conditions and assumptions.
  • Review results for accuracy and anomalies.
  • Confirm that simulations reflect real-world conditions.
  • Ensure documentation of simulation parameters is complete.
  • Review assembly drawings for clarity and completeness.
  • Assess the practicality of manufacturing processes outlined.
  • Check for potential assembly challenges or conflicts.
  • Evaluate any required special tooling or fixtures.
  • Ensure that manufacturing tolerances are achievable.
  • Identify applicable codes for the project.
  • Cross-reference designs with code requirements.
  • Document any deviations and justifications.
  • Ensure all necessary permits and approvals are in place.
  • Verify compliance with safety and environmental regulations.
  • Review safety factors applied to critical components.
  • Confirm that safety factors meet industry standards.
  • Check for consistency in safety factor application.
  • Evaluate the rationale for any non-standard values.
  • Document all safety factor calculations and assumptions.
  • Verify that all revisions are documented properly.
  • Check for appropriate approval signatures on changes.
  • Assess the impact of changes on project scope.
  • Ensure communication of changes to all stakeholders.
  • Review change history for trends in design modifications.
  • Confirm coordination with civil and electrical designs.
  • Review interdisciplinary design interfaces for conflicts.
  • Assess communication effectiveness among engineering teams.
  • Check for alignment with overall project goals.
  • Evaluate the impact of integration on project timelines.
  • Cross-check BOM against design drawings.
  • Ensure all components are accounted for.
  • Verify quantities and specifications listed.
  • Check for proper categorization of materials.
  • Assess the BOM for consistency with project requirements.
  • Review supplier certifications and quality reports.
  • Ensure traceability of materials to their source.
  • Check compliance of materials with specifications.
  • Evaluate any testing or inspection reports.
  • Assess the reliability of suppliers used.
  • Review analysis methods used for thermal calculations.
  • Check for adherence to fluid dynamics principles.
  • Evaluate performance predictions against benchmarks.
  • Document any assumptions made during assessments.
  • Ensure results align with operational requirements.
  • Assess accessibility for maintenance tasks.
  • Evaluate the design for ease of serviceability.
  • Check for incorporation of standard maintenance practices.
  • Review documentation for maintenance procedures.
  • Ensure that spare parts availability is considered.
  • Review designs for simplification opportunities.
  • Assess the number of parts for assembly efficiency.
  • Check for ease of handling and positioning of components.
  • Evaluate tooling and fixture requirements.
  • Ensure designs facilitate efficient assembly processes.
  • Review project documentation for past lessons learned.
  • Assess incorporation of best practices into design.
  • Evaluate alignment with industry standards.
  • Check for stakeholder feedback on previous projects.
  • Document any deviations from best practices.
  • Review meeting minutes for cross-discipline discussions.
  • Assess the use of collaborative tools and platforms.
  • Check for clarity in project roles and responsibilities.
  • Evaluate responsiveness to inter-team inquiries.
  • Document any barriers to effective communication.
  • Check test plans for compliance with industry standards.
  • Verify that all components are included in testing.
  • Assess the adequacy of test methodologies described.
  • Ensure clear documentation of test results.
  • Review contingency plans for test failures.
  • Review stress analysis results for critical components.
  • Evaluate environmental conditions considered in design.
  • Check for fatigue analysis where applicable.
  • Assess long-term performance predictions.
  • Document assumptions made about operating conditions.
  • Check designs against environmental regulations.
  • Assess the sustainability of material selections.
  • Document waste management practices in design.
  • Evaluate energy efficiency considerations.
  • Ensure compliance with relevant sustainability certifications.
  • Assess the realism of project schedules.
  • Check for alignment with overall project milestones.
  • Evaluate resource allocation against timelines.
  • Document any potential risks to meeting deadlines.
  • Ensure clarity of deliverables for all stakeholders.

3. Civil Engineering Audit

  • Review calculation methods used.
  • Verify assumptions and input parameters.
  • Ensure compliance with relevant standards.
  • Check for consistency in results.
  • Document any discrepancies found.
  • Ensure all necessary views and details are included.
  • Check dimensions and annotations for clarity.
  • Verify alignment with design calculations.
  • Confirm signature and date on drawings.
  • Identify any missing or outdated information.
  • Identify applicable codes for the project.
  • Verify that all design elements meet code requirements.
  • Document any variances or exceptions.
  • Consult with local authorities if needed.
  • Ensure proper licensing of involved professionals.
  • Review site survey reports for accuracy.
  • Assess environmental impact studies.
  • Check for compliance with environmental regulations.
  • Document potential environmental risks.
  • Ensure mitigation measures are proposed.
  • Verify calculations for drainage capacity.
  • Check for appropriate design of drainage systems.
  • Assess impacts on surrounding areas.
  • Ensure maintenance plans are included.
  • Document any potential flood risks.
  • Verify compliance with local building codes and regulations.
  • Check structural calculations for accuracy and completeness.
  • Review site plans for adherence to project specifications.
  • Assess material specifications against project requirements.
  • Ensure environmental considerations are documented and addressed.
  • Confirm that safety measures are integrated into design.
  • Evaluate drainage and erosion control plans for effectiveness.
  • Inspect geotechnical reports for relevancy and application.
  • Review soil test results for accuracy.
  • Check recommendations against design requirements.
  • Ensure compliance with geotechnical standards.
  • Document any soil-related concerns.
  • Confirm implementation of recommendations in design.
  • Review load calculations for design adequacy.
  • Check compliance with applicable seismic codes.
  • Assess wind load assumptions based on location.
  • Document any necessary design modifications.
  • Consult with structural engineers if needed.
  • Ensure coordination with other engineering teams.
  • Verify alignment of civil and mechanical designs.
  • Check for conflicts or overlaps in designs.
  • Document any integration issues identified.
  • Schedule meetings for interdisciplinary reviews.
  • Assess proposed methods against project requirements.
  • Check for logical sequencing of activities.
  • Identify potential challenges in execution.
  • Document any recommended changes.
  • Consult with construction managers for insights.
  • Review designs for temporary structures.
  • Check compliance with safety standards.
  • Assess load-bearing capacities.
  • Document any risks associated with temporary works.
  • Ensure regular inspections are planned.
  • Review design for safety features inclusion.
  • Check compliance with safety regulations.
  • Assess visibility and accessibility of safety measures.
  • Document any deficiencies found.
  • Consult safety experts if necessary.
  • Review material specifications against project standards.
  • Verify supplier qualifications and certifications.
  • Check compliance with sustainability criteria.
  • Document any material-related concerns.
  • Ensure proper documentation for material approvals.
  • Verify that all required permits are acquired.
  • Check for conditions attached to permits.
  • Document any pending approvals.
  • Ensure compliance with local regulations.
  • Consult legal advisors if needed.
  • Review cost breakdowns for accuracy.
  • Check for alignment with project budget.
  • Document any discrepancies or risks.
  • Consult with cost estimators for insights.
  • Ensure contingency funds are included.
  • Review site access plans for feasibility.
  • Check for equipment movement and storage areas.
  • Assess worker safety and access routes.
  • Document any logistical challenges.
  • Ensure compliance with local traffic regulations.
  • Verify compliance with environmental regulations.
  • Check for effectiveness of proposed measures.
  • Document potential erosion risks.
  • Ensure regular monitoring is planned.
  • Consult environmental specialists if needed.
  • Review sustainability goals set for the project.
  • Verify compliance with green building standards.
  • Assess overall environmental impact.
  • Document any sustainability deficiencies.
  • Consult with sustainability experts for improvements.

4. Electrical, Instrumentation, and Control (EIC) Audit

  • Check load analysis for accuracy and completeness.
  • Ensure short circuit calculations comply with standards.
  • Verify assumptions and input parameters used in calculations.
  • Review calculations for all major electrical components.
  • Document any discrepancies or required adjustments.
  • Review specifications for accuracy and compliance.
  • Ensure selected instruments meet project requirements.
  • Check calibration ranges and accuracy standards.
  • Verify compatibility with existing systems.
  • Document rationale for instrumentation choices.
  • Examine architecture for clarity and completeness.
  • Verify that logic diagrams accurately represent functionality.
  • Check for consistency with project specifications.
  • Assess redundancy and fail-safety features.
  • Document any design inconsistencies or issues.
  • Review designs against relevant safety standards.
  • Verify compliance with electrical codes.
  • Check documentation for standard references.
  • Identify any non-compliance issues.
  • Document corrective actions required.
  • Check for alignment with mechanical design specifications.
  • Assess interfaces between EIC and other systems.
  • Review coordination of installation plans.
  • Document any integration issues identified.
  • Ensure communication pathways are defined.
  • Review grounding plans for compliance with standards.
  • Inspect physical grounding systems on-site.
  • Ensure proper bonding of all conductive parts.
  • Document any deficiencies or potential improvements.
  • Verify testing results of grounding systems.
  • Check cable sizing against load requirements.
  • Verify conduit sizing complies with industry standards.
  • Inspect routing for accessibility and safety.
  • Document any deviations from design specifications.
  • Ensure protection against environmental factors.
  • Review design for dual power supply options.
  • Check backup systems for reliability.
  • Assess monitoring systems for power supply status.
  • Document potential single points of failure.
  • Ensure redundancy meets project needs.
  • Review specifications for appropriateness to application.
  • Check performance criteria against industry standards.
  • Verify device ratings match system requirements.
  • Document any performance concerns identified.
  • Ensure installation follows specified guidelines.
  • Inspect layout for accessibility and maintenance.
  • Check thermal management features are adequate.
  • Ensure proper labeling of components.
  • Document any layout or thermal issues.
  • Verify compliance with safety regulations.
  • Review calibration procedures for completeness.
  • Check documentation for adherence to standards.
  • Ensure traceability of calibration records.
  • Assess frequency of calibration checks.
  • Document any discrepancies found.
  • Review sensor and actuator specifications.
  • Check placement against process flow requirements.
  • Ensure accessibility for maintenance.
  • Document any placement issues.
  • Verify compatibility with control systems.
  • Check compatibility of protocols used.
  • Verify data transmission methods comply with standards.
  • Assess latency and reliability of communication.
  • Document any communication issues identified.
  • Ensure redundancy in communication paths.
  • Review design for compliance with safety regulations.
  • Verify documentation includes all necessary procedures.
  • Check testing results of shutdown systems.
  • Document any issues or improvements needed.
  • Ensure training on emergency procedures is provided.
  • Review software documentation for completeness.
  • Check for compliance with industry standards.
  • Ensure validation procedures are in place.
  • Document any software issues identified.
  • Verify update and maintenance procedures.
  • Check manuals against project specifications.
  • Ensure clarity and usability of documentation.
  • Document any missing or unclear information.
  • Verify inclusion of all necessary procedures.
  • Assess training needs based on manual content.
  • Review training programs for comprehensiveness.
  • Ensure alignment with operational manuals.
  • Document personnel training needs.
  • Check for certification requirements.
  • Verify ongoing training plans are in place.
  • Inspect physical installations against design documents.
  • Check for compliance with safety standards.
  • Document any installation deficiencies found.
  • Verify quality control measures were followed.
  • Assess general site conditions and access.
  • Check plans for comprehensiveness and clarity.
  • Ensure alignment with project specifications.
  • Document any testing requirements or issues.
  • Verify timelines for testing and commissioning.
  • Assess personnel assigned to testing roles.
  • Review performance data for trends and anomalies.
  • Check maintenance logs for frequency of issues.
  • Document any recurring problems identified.
  • Assess impact of historical data on current designs.
  • Use data to inform future maintenance strategies.

5. Quality Assurance and Control

  • Identify existing quality control measures.
  • Review documentation of quality control procedures.
  • Interview personnel responsible for quality control.
  • Observe quality control processes in action.
  • Assess the effectiveness of current processes.
  • Verify the adequacy of inspection plans.
  • Ensure testing methods align with project requirements.
  • Check for approval status of inspection and testing plans.
  • Review schedules for inspections and tests.
  • Confirm resources are allocated for inspections.
  • Examine records of non-conformities.
  • Review corrective action reports and responses.
  • Assess the timeliness of corrective actions taken.
  • Ensure follow-up actions are documented.
  • Verify trends in non-conformities are analyzed.
  • Identify applicable ISO standards for the project.
  • Review compliance documentation.
  • Conduct interviews with quality assurance personnel.
  • Evaluate training on ISO standards.
  • Check for third-party audits and reports.
  • Verify qualifications of quality assurance staff.
  • Review training records for relevance and currency.
  • Assess ongoing training programs.
  • Ensure personnel are certified as required.
  • Check for cross-training opportunities.
  • Review internal audit schedules and reports.
  • Assess the scope and objectives of audits.
  • Evaluate the implementation of audit recommendations.
  • Check for consistency in audit findings.
  • Ensure corrective actions are tracked.
  • Review QMS documentation and policies.
  • Check alignment of QMS with project goals.
  • Evaluate employee understanding of QMS.
  • Assess integration of QMS in daily operations.
  • Identify areas for improvement in QMS.
  • Review material sourcing documentation.
  • Check for tracking systems of materials.
  • Ensure records support traceability requirements.
  • Evaluate processes for identifying non-conforming materials.
  • Confirm traceability from supplier to site.
  • Compile findings from past audits.
  • Assess the resolution status of identified issues.
  • Verify corrective actions taken were effective.
  • Evaluate trends in audit results over time.
  • Ensure lessons learned are documented.
  • Review quality control documentation for completeness.
  • Check records management practices.
  • Ensure documents are accessible and up-to-date.
  • Assess compliance with record retention policies.
  • Verify that documentation supports audit trails.
  • Review SPC techniques applied in the project.
  • Assess data collection methods for SPC.
  • Evaluate the effectiveness of SPC in identifying trends.
  • Check for training on SPC methods.
  • Examine reports generated from SPC analysis.
  • Review supplier quality management processes.
  • Check records of incoming inspections.
  • Evaluate supplier performance metrics.
  • Assess the communication of quality issues with suppliers.
  • Confirm corrective actions taken with suppliers.
  • Collect and analyze client feedback data.
  • Assess trends in client satisfaction over time.
  • Identify areas for improvement based on feedback.
  • Ensure responsiveness to client concerns.
  • Document changes made in response to feedback.
  • Review documentation of past project lessons learned.
  • Assess mechanisms for capturing continuous improvement initiatives.
  • Evaluate the implementation of improvement recommendations.
  • Check for regular reviews of improvement processes.
  • Document the impact of improvements on quality.
  • Review maintenance schedules for testing equipment.
  • Check calibration records for compliance.
  • Assess procedures for equipment maintenance.
  • Ensure equipment is functioning as intended.
  • Verify that records are up-to-date and accessible.
  • Review project quality standards documentation.
  • Check alignment of work with specifications.
  • Assess adherence to quality metrics defined in the project.
  • Evaluate the processes for addressing deviations.
  • Document compliance status and issues.
  • Review communication protocols for quality issues.
  • Assess the effectiveness of reporting mechanisms.
  • Evaluate stakeholder engagement in quality discussions.
  • Confirm timely distribution of quality reports.
  • Document feedback received from stakeholders.

6. Risk Management Review

  • Gather input from project team members.
  • Review project scope and objectives.
  • Conduct brainstorming sessions to identify risks.
  • Develop a list of potential risks and categorize them.
  • Identify mitigation strategies for each risk.
  • Collect all current risk assessment documents.
  • Check for the latest updates and revisions.
  • Ensure assessments align with project changes.
  • Discuss findings with the project team.
  • Document any necessary adjustments.
  • Identify key stakeholders involved in risk management.
  • Verify their participation in risk assessment meetings.
  • Gather feedback on their concerns and suggestions.
  • Ensure stakeholders receive regular updates.
  • Document their roles in the risk management process.
  • Review existing contingency plans.
  • Evaluate the feasibility of each plan.
  • Identify critical components requiring contingency measures.
  • Assess resource availability for implementation.
  • Update plans based on current project status.
  • Review performance data related to implemented strategies.
  • Gather team feedback on strategy effectiveness.
  • Identify areas needing improvement.
  • Make recommendations for adjustments.
  • Document findings and proposed changes.
  • Collect data from previous projects.
  • Identify patterns or recurring risks.
  • Assess the impact of these risks on past projects.
  • Compile a list of common risks.
  • Incorporate findings into current risk management.
  • Identify relevant industry standards and regulations.
  • Assess current project practices against these guidelines.
  • Document any compliance gaps.
  • Recommend corrective actions.
  • Engage legal or compliance teams if necessary.
  • Schedule interviews or workshops with team members.
  • Prepare questions focused on risk identification.
  • Encourage open dialogue and brainstorming.
  • Document insights and observations.
  • Share findings with the project team.
  • Identify key risk indicators for the project.
  • Establish a monitoring schedule.
  • Collect data on performance metrics regularly.
  • Analyze trends and deviations.
  • Report findings to stakeholders.
  • Gather lessons learned documentation from past phases.
  • Identify applicable lessons for current projects.
  • Discuss findings with the project team.
  • Integrate lessons into risk management strategies.
  • Ensure documentation is accessible for future reference.
  • Review current risk management tools and resources.
  • Evaluate their effectiveness and user-friendliness.
  • Identify additional resources if needed.
  • Gather team feedback on tool utilization.
  • Make recommendations for enhancements.
  • Assess the current communication plan.
  • Identify key stakeholders and their information needs.
  • Ensure timely updates are scheduled.
  • Document channels for communication.
  • Recommend improvements to the plan.
  • Review project management documentation.
  • Ensure risk management roles are defined.
  • Assess how risks are tracked and reported.
  • Evaluate alignment with project objectives.
  • Document any discrepancies and recommend changes.
  • Determine the frequency of risk review meetings.
  • Schedule meetings in advance and share with stakeholders.
  • Establish a consistent agenda for each meeting.
  • Document outcomes and action items.
  • Adjust the timeline as needed.

7. Final Reporting and Recommendations

  • Collect data from all audit phases.
  • Organize findings by category: compliance, performance, and risk.
  • Highlight discrepancies and notable observations.
  • Ensure clarity and accuracy in data representation.
  • Align recommendations with audit findings.
  • Prioritize based on impact and feasibility.
  • Ensure each recommendation is specific and clear.
  • Consider resource availability for implementation.
  • Draft the report using a standard template.
  • Include an executive summary of key findings.
  • Incorporate recommendations with supporting evidence.
  • Ensure the report is clear and concise.
  • Determine the appropriate timeframe for follow-up.
  • Communicate scheduling needs to stakeholders.
  • Ensure follow-up aligns with project timelines.
  • Document the purpose and scope of the follow-up.
  • Highlight areas of excellence and best practices.
  • Identify significant weaknesses and risk areas.
  • Provide context for each strength and weakness.
  • Ensure summaries are clear and understandable.
  • Categorize actions by urgency and importance.
  • Assign timelines for each action item.
  • Include responsible parties for accountability.
  • Review and adjust priorities as necessary.
  • Prepare a visual presentation of key insights.
  • Engage stakeholders with interactive discussion.
  • Highlight implications of findings and recommendations.
  • Provide opportunities for stakeholder input.
  • Record management's positions on each finding.
  • Include timelines for response implementation.
  • Ensure management feedback is clear and actionable.
  • Attach responses directly to the audit report.
  • Define clear performance indicators.
  • Ensure metrics are measurable and achievable.
  • Set review periods for measuring outcomes.
  • Communicate metrics to all relevant parties.
  • Assign a lead for each recommendation.
  • Ensure clarity regarding roles and responsibilities.
  • Document accountability in the action plan.
  • Review assignments with management.
  • Collect feedback systematically from all stakeholders.
  • Evaluate feedback for relevance and applicability.
  • Revise the report based on constructive suggestions.
  • Document changes made in response to feedback.
  • Compile all supporting documents.
  • Cross-reference documents throughout the report.
  • Ensure all attachments are clearly labeled.
  • Review for completeness before final submission.
  • Set a date and time for the meeting.
  • Prepare an agenda focused on lessons learned.
  • Encourage open discussion among team members.
  • Document insights for future audits.
  • Specify actions for continued oversight.
  • Set timelines for regular reviews.
  • Identify key metrics for ongoing evaluation.
  • Communicate next steps to stakeholders.

Related Checklists